As a proposed development grows, so can the transportation analysis that is required as part of Fairfax County’s entitlement process.
In Part 1 of this series, we examined Fairfax County’s Tier 1 Transportation Statement and Tier 2 Comprehensive Transportation Analysis-Zoning (CTA-Z), which generally apply to developments generating fewer than 3,000 net new average daily trips (ADT).
But what happens when a development exceeds that threshold?
For projects that generate 3,000 or more net new daily trips (note: Part 1 explains the concept of net new daily trips), the required transportation analysis can expand considerably – including an examination of transportation conditions beyond the immediate development site. At 5,000 net new trips, Virginia’s Chapter 870 Traffic Impact Analysis requirements generally come into play.
Here is what you can expect under both these scenarios.
Tier 3 Begins at 3,000 Net New Daily Trips
Development that are expected to generate between 3,000 and 4,999 net new ADT generally requires a Tier 3 CTA-Z.
Like Tier 2, Tier 3 evaluates transportation conditions under existing conditions, future conditions without the proposed development, and future conditions with the development.
It also considers multiple modes of transportation, including:
- Driving
- Walking
- Bicycling
- Public transportation
But the size of the project can warrant an examination of transportation and traffic networks that exist beyond and/or adjacent to the boundaries of the site in question.
A Tier 3 Study Can Extend Beyond the Property
One of the important differences between Tier 2 and Tier 3 involves the extent of the vehicular analysis.
Tier 2 generally concentrates on site access points, streets along the site’s frontage, and intersections along its perimeter. That is pretty straightforward.
With Tier 3, however, the analysis can extend to relevant off-site intersections identified through the scoping process.
For a developer, this distinction can be significant.
This means that traffic conditions several intersections away from the property may become part of the transportation analysis. Existing or anticipated congestion, other planned developments, future roadway improvements, and the distribution of traffic generated by the proposed development can all influence the scope.
As we stated in Part 1 of this discuss, this increased scope is another reason why transportation planning can be valuable early in the development process: a project’s transportation considerations do not necessarily stop at the property line.
The Top Level: At 5,000 Trips, Chapter 870 Comes Into Play
When a proposed development is expected to generate 5,000 or more net new ADT, a VDOT Chapter 870 Traffic Impact Analysis generally is required.
Chapter 870 establishes Virginia’s requirements for traffic impact analyses associated with certain land-use proposals.
These studies can address a wide range of transportation issues such as:
- Intersection level of service
- Traffic queues and delay
- Access management
- Intersection spacing
- Other traffic impacts associated with the proposed development
Although Chapter 870 is a VDOT requirement, FCDOT determines whether it applies to a specific Fairfax County application. The resulting TIA is scoped and reviewed by VDOT in coordination with FCDOT. Larger developments can get complicated!
CTA-Z multimodal elements also may be incorporated into the study, allowing the development’s vehicular and broader transportation impacts to be considered through a coordinated process.
Scoping Becomes Particularly Important for Larger Projects
For larger developments, our experience has shown that defining the transportation study before performing the analysis is an important part of the process.
In these cases, the applicant’s transportation consultant prepares the pre-scoping information, and FCDOT and VDOT participate in establishing the scope.
Questions that can be addressed during scoping vary, and may include:
- Which intersections should be analyzed?
- How far should the study area extend?
- What background developments should be incorporated?
- What planned transportation improvements should be assumed?
- How should development traffic be distributed across the roadway network?
- What pedestrian, bicycle, and transit conditions should be evaluated?
Once FCDOT and VDOT approve the scope, the transportation consultant proceeds with the study.
For a developer, resolving these questions early can reduce the risk of completing substantial analysis only to discover that additional intersections, assumptions, or scenarios need to be evaluated.
A Larger Study Area Can Mean Larger Development Considerations
Now, we want to make clear that the significance of a Tier 3 or Chapter 870 study doesn’t simply mean that you have to produce a larger traffic report.
Importantly, the analysis may identify transportation issues that become part of discussions among the applicant, Fairfax County, VDOT, neighboring properties, and other stakeholders during the entitlement process.
Depending on the project and its impacts, potential considerations might include improvements to intersections or access points, changes to site access, pedestrian and bicycle connections, or other transportation strategies.
We also want to point out that not every transportation issue that is identified by a traffic impact analysis will necessarily become the responsibility of a particular development. But understanding those conditions early gives the development team more opportunity to evaluate alternatives and incorporate transportation considerations into the overall entitlement strategy.
Remember: The Threshold Is Still Based on Net New Trips
As we discussed in Part 1, the applicable Fairfax County threshold is based on the development’s net new trips compared with the trips associated with the property’s by-right use.
This remains important at the upper tiers.
A proposed redevelopment that generates more than 5,000 daily trips does not necessarily generate 5,000 net new trips. Conversely, a significant increase in development intensity could move a proposal from Tier 2 into Tier 3—or across the Chapter 870 threshold.
This means that “trip generation” – which is the metric that defines so much of this process – therefore can be more than a technical calculation performed merely for a transportation report. It can help the development team understand the transportation review process it is likely to encounter. Those trip generation numbers help define your strategy.
Transportation Analysis as Part of Entitlement Strategy
For a large development or redevelopment in Fairfax County, transportation planning should not necessarily begin after the site plan and development program are largely complete.
Evaluating transportation conditions early can help developers and property owners understand:
- Which transportation analysis requirements are likely to apply
- How extensive the study area may be
- Which existing transportation constraints could affect the project
- What multimodal considerations may need to be addressed
- Which transportation improvements or strategies could become relevant during review
- The location of site driveways, loading docks, access management, and consideration of area-specific design standards such as the Tysons Corner Urban Center or applicable VDOT standards
This type of information can help the larger development team make informed decisions before significant time and resources have been committed to a particular approach.
Planning a Development or Redevelopment in Fairfax County?
Wells + Associates has been working with developers, property owners, civil engineers, attorneys, architects, and other members of development teams for over thirty years to evaluate transportation issues, prepare required transportation analyses, coordinate with Fairfax County and VDOT, and develop practical strategies for addressing transportation impacts.
Whether a project requires a Tier 1 Transportation Statement, CTA-Z, or Chapter 870 TIA, understanding the transportation requirements early can help establish a clearer path through the entitlement process.